1 1

Build Your Case

Build Your Case

$109.00

4.3
Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
39 Reviews

Case File

The delicious evidence is mounting. It's time to build a case against your hunger by selecting exactly which flavors you want delivered, to your house, from the list below.

Size
$109.00
Shipping $25.00 FREE SHIPPING
Build My Case

INCLUDED IN THIS CASE

  • 6 Pints of Award-Winning LIMITED EDITION Luxury Ice Cream (Featured Below)
  • 1 Silver Shovel Spoon
View full details

Shipping Popup

We take pride in offering luxury products to your door in the best possible condition on the requested delivery date. Each cold cooler box utilizes carefully engineered packaging and dry ice to keep the delivery cold when it arrives on your doorstep.

Unfortunately, sometimes things happen that are outside of our control like weather and transi delays once the package is in the hands of FedEx or UPS. As such, the shipping guidelines published on this website are not guarandtees of a shipping or arrival date.

Cold Case is unable to guarantee the time of delivery, as this is all subject to the local carr

Select your Flavors:

Flight Risk
+

Flight Risk

Vanilla ice cream layered with cookie butter chunks and cookie butter swirls covered in golden cinnamon cream.

Assaulted Caramel
+

Assaulted Caramel

Rich salted caramel ice cream melded with Madagascar vanilla and fresh cream.

Trial By Chocolate
+

Trial By Chocolate

Sweet and creamy Cocoa ice cream infused with pure Madagascar vanilla.

Embezzle-mint
+

Embezzle-mint

Madagascar vanilla ice cream mixed with fresh mint leaf and semi sweet chocolate stracciatella.

Killer Bees
+

Killer Bees

Sweet cream base infused with drizzles of fresh honey and chunks of honeycomb candy.

Cookies & Scream
+

Cookies & Scream

Sweet cream ice cream covered in a gratuitous amount of Oreo cookie chunks.

Creamy Contraband
+

Creamy Contraband

Fresh sweet cream ice cream base mingled with pure Madagascar vanilla.

Strawburied Alive

Strawburied Alive

Sweet cream base blended with fresh strawberries.

Jane Dough
+

Jane Dough

Sweet cream base with golden syrup and Belgian chocolate chip cookie dough & cookie chunks.

Rocky Railroad Robbery
+

Rocky Railroad Robbery

Dark chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, homemade almond brittle and vanilla marshmallow fluff swirls.

Cereal Killer
+

Cereal Killer

Milk chocolate base with homemade muddy buddy cereal mix with swirls of peanut butter.

Peanut Butter Smother

Peanut Butter Smother

Crunchy peanut butter sandwich cookies dunked into a tub of chocolate ice cream and blanketed with swirls of creamy peanut butter. 

Key Lime Killer

Key Lime Killer

A tantalizing blend of tangy key lime ice cream, enriched with marshmallow meringue, and slashed with crunchy graham cracker crust.

Puffed Pyro

Puffed Pyro

A caramelized blaze ignites! Creamy marshmallow ice cream melded with fiery toasted marshmallow chunks for a flavor that will set your taste buds ablaze.

Crime Brûlée

Crime Brûlée

Smooth vanilla custard ice cream with smuggled shards of golden crystallized burnt sugar. Each scoop demands respect and expands its tasty territory. 

Boys in Blueberry Muffin

Boys in Blueberry Muffin

Let frozen justice reign! Fresh blueberry ice cream and spunky blueberry muffin chunks. It's a flavor that cuffs your taste buds with sweet satisfaction.

Bordeaux Bribe

Bordeaux Bribe

A tempting offer arrives: Brown sugar ice cream with decadent milk chocolate waves awaits. What's a little rich chocolate ganache for a few favors?

Gingerbread Man-slaughter

Gingerbread Man-slaughter

Gingerbread ice cream with chunks of gingerbread cookie and swirls of cream cheese frosting.

Crime and Punish-mint

Crime and Punish-mint

Finely ground peppermint pieces with chocolate sandwich cookie chunks perfectly blended in peppermint ice cream.

Cartel de Churros

Cartel de Churros

Mexican cinnamon hot chocolate ice cream, cayenne pepper seasoning and San Diablo Churro bites.

Looking for Something a Little More Premium?

Expertly Hand-Crafted Flavors

From familiar classics to fresh new favorites, our award-winning chef has spent years methodically crafting the most premium ice cream you’ll ever experience. Lock your doors, you’re not going to want to share this evidence with anyone.

Shop Now

INVESTIGATE OUR

Eye Witness Testimonials

“This ice cream is insane! I loved EVERY. SINGLE. BITE. Where did they get these ingredients? They were fancy AF. Honestly, the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted in my life. Case closed!”
Joseph R. [REDACTED]

“In a word, epic. The flavors were so wild and different. I’ve never had ice cream that was so different and yet so familiar. Like pineapple & cornbread?! Who knew. It was like all my favorite flavors on steroids.”
Renny G. [REDACTED]

“I had really high expectations because of the price. KEEP your expectations high. This isn’t just the best ice cream I’ve ever had it was the best dessert I’ve ever had, period. “
Eden M. [REDACTED]
4.3
Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
Based on 39 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 25 Total 4 star reviews: 5 Total 3 star reviews: 7 Total 2 star reviews: 0 Total 1 star reviews: 2
77%would recommend this product
Slide 1 selected
Powered by OkendoOpen Okendo Reviews in a new window
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
39 reviews
  • Barry K.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    2 weeks ago
    Taste Is Everything

    The taste of this ice cream is simply the most smooth and delicious I've ever tasted.

    The Mint was so refreshing and the chocolate dreamy.

    Was this helpful?
    Cold Case Ice Cream
    20 seconds ago

    Thank you for the kind words! Smooth, refreshing, and dreamy are exactly what we aim for with every scoop. We're thrilled the Mint and Chocolate flavors delivered such a luxurious experience for you. Enjoy indulging!

  • Matthew S.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 month ago
    Family Favorite

    My girlfriend and her family had so much fun with this and absolutely loved the ice cream

    Was this helpful?
    Cold Case Ice Cream
    1 month ago

    That’s amazing to hear! We love knowing Cold Case brought joy to your girlfriend and her family. Here’s to many more shared moments and indulgent scoops!

  • Richard
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 months ago
    5 Stars

    I enjoyed it

    Was this helpful?
    Cold Case Ice Cream
    3 months ago
    We're glad to hear you enjoyed it! Simple pleasures are what Cold Case is all about. Thanks for choosing us!
Reviews LoadedReviews Added

FAQs

WHEN WILL THERE BE NEW FLAVORS?

Curious about what we've got planned? Sign up for our email list to find out, but keep in mind - snitches get stitches. Hint: it's coming sooner than you think.

HOW DO YOU SHIP ICE CREAM?

We don't mess around with our frozen goods - we give them the VIP treatment, packing them in an insulated shipping box with enough dry ice to keep them colder than the hearts of the most devious of criminals. At a frigid -109.3°F, these frozen culprits are ready to be delivered in perfect condition.

CAN I PURCHASE MULTIPLE BOXES FOR CORPORATE GIFTING?

Yes! It’s possibly the easiest yet most thoughtful gift you could give vendors, contractors, clients, or a whole customer service team. (Let’s face it, they are the backbone of this economy) If you’re looking to place an order of 5 or more, head here, fill out the form, and our team will get back to you!.