Skip to content
Delivery Instructions
Save
Cancel
Your cart is empty
Build My Own Case
Have an account?
Log in to check out faster.
FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS
NOMINATE SOMEONE AND
Win Flavorless Ice Cream!
Here at Cold Case Ice Cream, we're all about the bold and the beautiful in ice cream flavors. But guess what?
We've heard that some folks think our creations are too much of a good thing.
For those with... let's say 'numb tongues', we've introduced Flavorless Ice Cream.
It's as unadventurous as it gets, perfect for those who prefer their world a little less flavorful.
But, for the rest of you flavor daredevils who want unique, hand-crafted, premium ice creams made for grown ups who want to suck the marrow out of life, shop Cold Case Ice Cream by clicking on the "Shop" buttons below.
Flavors in this case:
Better Than Sex Cake Chocolate ice cream with chocolate cake soaked with caramel & condensed milk with homemade toffee bits and marshmallow swirls.
Raspberry Ransom Raspberry ice cream with a white chocolate ganache swirl and cinnamon brownie chunks.
Miami Ice Pina colada dairy-free ice cream with coconut cream, pineapple, and a strawberry balsamic swirl.
Filter By:
All Products
Most Popular
Classic Creams
Chocolate Lovers
Fruit Fusion
Nutty & Crunchy
Spiced & Seasonal
+
America's Most Wanted
America's Most Wanted
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Goat cheese, Blackberry Jam, Sliced Almonds, Butter, Brown Sugar, Honey, Rosemary
View more product details
+
Assaulted Caramel
Assaulted Caramel
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Rich salted caramel ice cream melded with Madagascar vanilla and fresh cream. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Blackmail
Blackmail
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base infused with edible charcoal, swirls of marshmallow fluff, & cookie sandwich chunks
View more product details
+
Bordeaux Bribe
Bordeaux Bribe
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
A tempting offer arrives: Brown sugar ice cream with decadent milk chocolate waves awaits. What's a little rich chocolate ganache for a few favors?
View more product details
+
Boys in Blueberry Muffin
Boys in Blueberry Muffin
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Let frozen justice reign! Fresh blueberry ice cream and spunky blueberry muffin chunks. It's a flavor that cuffs your taste buds with sweet satisfaction.
View more product details
+
Cereal Killer
Cereal Killer
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Milk chocolate base with homemade muddy buddy cereal mix with swirls of peanut butter. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Convict Crunch
Convict Crunch
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Dark chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, homemade almond brittle and vanilla marshmallow fluff swirls
View more product details
+
Cookie Mobster
Cookie Mobster
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Blue sweet cream base, chocolate sandwich cookie pieces, Cookie Dough Bites, Circus Animal Cookies
View more product details
+
Cookies & Scream
Cookies & Scream
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream ice cream covered in a gratuitous amount of oreo cookie chunks. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Creamy Contraband
Creamy Contraband
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Fresh sweet cream ice cream base mingled with pure Madagascar vanilla. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Crime and Punish-mint
Crime and Punish-mint
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Finely ground peppermint pieces with chocolate sandwich cookie chunks perfectly blended in peppermint ice cream.
View more product details
+
Crime Brûlée
Crime Brûlée
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Smooth vanilla custard ice cream with smuggled shards of golden crystallized burnt sugar. Each scoop demands respect and expands its tasty territory.
View more product details
+
Embezzle-mint
Embezzle-mint
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Madagascar vanilla ice cream mixed with fresh mint leaf and semi sweet chocolate stracciatella. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Flight Risk
Flight Risk
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Vanilla ice cream layered with cookie butter chunks and cookie butter swirls covered in golden cinnamon cream. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Gingerbread Man-slaughter
Gingerbread Man-slaughter
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Gingerbread ice cream with chunks of gingerbread cookie and swirls of cream cheese frosting.
View more product details
+
Huckleberry Pie Witness
Huckleberry Pie Witness
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Huckleberries, Huckleberry jam, graham cracker pie crust, spices
View more product details
+
Illegal Fireworks
Illegal Fireworks
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Cake batter ice cream, blue and red White Fudge-coated Popping candy
View more product details
+
Jane Dough
Jane Dough
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base with golden syrup and Belgian chocolate chip cookie dough & cookie chunks. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Key Lime Killer
Key Lime Killer
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
A tantalizing blend of tangy key lime ice cream, enriched with marshmallow meringue, and slashed with crunchy graham cracker crust.
View more product details
+
Killer Bees
Killer Bees
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base infused with drizzles of fresh honey and chunks of honeycomb candy. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Killer Bees
Killer Bees
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream ice cream infused with drizzles of fresh honey and chunks of honeycomb candy
View more product details
+
Peanut Butter Smother
Peanut Butter Smother
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Crunchy peanut butter sandwich cookies dunked into a tub of chocolate ice cream and blanketed with swirls of creamy peanut butter.
View more product details
+
Stone Cold Killer
Stone Cold Killer
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base, Brownie, Chocolate-covered waffle cone pieces, fudge swirl
View more product details
+
Strawburied Alive
Strawburied Alive
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base blended with fresh strawberries. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Summer Camp Massacre
Summer Camp Massacre
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Vanilla base, Graham Crackers, Brown Sugar, Chocolate Shavings, Marshmallow swirl
View more product details
+
Trial By Chocolate
Trial By Chocolate
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet and creamy Cocoa ice cream infused with pure Madagascar vanilla. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
Trial by Chocolate
Trial by Chocolate
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet and creamy cocoa ice cream infused with pure Madagascar vanilla.
View more product details
INVESTIGATE OUR
Eye Witness Testimonials
“This ice cream is insane! I loved EVERY. SINGLE. BITE. Where did they get these ingredients? They were fancy AF. Honestly, the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted in my life. Case closed!”
“In a word, epic. The flavors were so wild and different. I’ve never had ice cream that was so different and yet so familiar. Like pineapple & cornbread?! Who knew. It was like all my favorite flavors on steroids.”
“I had really high expectations because of the price. KEEP your expectations high. This isn’t just the best ice cream I’ve ever had it was the best dessert I’ve ever had, period. “
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.
Build My Case
Close My Case
Filter By:
All Products
Most Popular
Classic Creams
Chocolate Lovers
Fruit Fusion
Nutty & Crunchy
Spiced & Seasonal
+
−
1
+
America's Most Wanted
America's Most Wanted
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Goat cheese, Blackberry Jam, Sliced Almonds, Butter, Brown Sugar, Honey, Rosemary
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Assaulted Caramel
Assaulted Caramel
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Rich salted caramel ice cream melded with Madagascar vanilla and fresh cream. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Blackmail
Blackmail
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base infused with edible charcoal, swirls of marshmallow fluff, & cookie sandwich chunks
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Bordeaux Bribe
Bordeaux Bribe
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
A tempting offer arrives: Brown sugar ice cream with decadent milk chocolate waves awaits. What's a little rich chocolate ganache for a few favors?
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Boys in Blueberry Muffin
Boys in Blueberry Muffin
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Let frozen justice reign! Fresh blueberry ice cream and spunky blueberry muffin chunks. It's a flavor that cuffs your taste buds with sweet satisfaction.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Cereal Killer
Cereal Killer
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Milk chocolate base with homemade muddy buddy cereal mix with swirls of peanut butter. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Convict Crunch
Convict Crunch
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Dark chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, homemade almond brittle and vanilla marshmallow fluff swirls
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Cookie Mobster
Cookie Mobster
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Blue sweet cream base, chocolate sandwich cookie pieces, Cookie Dough Bites, Circus Animal Cookies
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Cookies & Scream
Cookies & Scream
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream ice cream covered in a gratuitous amount of oreo cookie chunks. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Creamy Contraband
Creamy Contraband
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Fresh sweet cream ice cream base mingled with pure Madagascar vanilla. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Crime and Punish-mint
Crime and Punish-mint
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Finely ground peppermint pieces with chocolate sandwich cookie chunks perfectly blended in peppermint ice cream.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Crime Brûlée
Crime Brûlée
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Smooth vanilla custard ice cream with smuggled shards of golden crystallized burnt sugar. Each scoop demands respect and expands its tasty territory.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Embezzle-mint
Embezzle-mint
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Madagascar vanilla ice cream mixed with fresh mint leaf and semi sweet chocolate stracciatella. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Flight Risk
Flight Risk
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Vanilla ice cream layered with cookie butter chunks and cookie butter swirls covered in golden cinnamon cream. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Gingerbread Man-slaughter
Gingerbread Man-slaughter
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Gingerbread ice cream with chunks of gingerbread cookie and swirls of cream cheese frosting.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Huckleberry Pie Witness
Huckleberry Pie Witness
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Huckleberries, Huckleberry jam, graham cracker pie crust, spices
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Illegal Fireworks
Illegal Fireworks
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Cake batter ice cream, blue and red White Fudge-coated Popping candy
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Jane Dough
Jane Dough
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base with golden syrup and Belgian chocolate chip cookie dough & cookie chunks. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Key Lime Killer
Key Lime Killer
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
A tantalizing blend of tangy key lime ice cream, enriched with marshmallow meringue, and slashed with crunchy graham cracker crust.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Killer Bees
Killer Bees
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base infused with drizzles of fresh honey and chunks of honeycomb candy. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Killer Bees
Killer Bees
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream ice cream infused with drizzles of fresh honey and chunks of honeycomb candy
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Peanut Butter Smother
Peanut Butter Smother
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Crunchy peanut butter sandwich cookies dunked into a tub of chocolate ice cream and blanketed with swirls of creamy peanut butter.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Stone Cold Killer
Stone Cold Killer
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base, Brownie, Chocolate-covered waffle cone pieces, fudge swirl
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Strawburied Alive
Strawburied Alive
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet cream base blended with fresh strawberries. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Summer Camp Massacre
Summer Camp Massacre
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Vanilla base, Graham Crackers, Brown Sugar, Chocolate Shavings, Marshmallow swirl
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Trial By Chocolate
Trial By Chocolate
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet and creamy Cocoa ice cream infused with pure Madagascar vanilla. Add 1, 2, or even 6 of this flavor to your 'Build My Case' box.
View more product details
+
−
1
+
Trial by Chocolate
Trial by Chocolate
Pint of Luxury Ice Cream
The Evidence:
Sweet and creamy cocoa ice cream infused with pure Madagascar vanilla.
View more product details
$149.99
Shipping $25.00
FREE SHIPPING
-
HOW IT WORKS
Choose six luxury hand-crafted flavours to piece together your perfect case.
Select "+" next to the flavour to add it to your box.
Pick a multiple of the same flavour or one of each for a chilly mystery.
-
Flavors Included:
0 /6
Select 6 more flavors
Your case is full
{"statementLink":"","footerHtml":"","hideMobile":false,"hideTrigger":false,"disableBgProcess":false,"language":"en","position":"left","leadColor":"#146ff8","triggerColor":"#146ff8","triggerRadius":"50%","triggerPositionX":"right","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerIcon":"people","triggerSize":"medium","triggerOffsetX":20,"triggerOffsetY":20,"mobile":{"triggerSize":"small","triggerPositionX":"right","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerOffsetX":10,"triggerOffsetY":10,"triggerRadius":"50%"}}