NOMINATE SOMEONE AND

Win Flavorless Ice Cream!

Here at Cold Case Ice Cream we've gotten some reviews that say our ice cream is too exotic, expensive, and dangerously delectable, with far too many luxuriously wild flavors.

So we created Flavorless Ice Cream! Flavorless Ice Cream is a cheap ice cream for any "numb tongues" out there with completely boring taste buds, who think ketchup is spicy. If this describes someone you know, nominate them below & if chosen we'll send them a tub of Flavorless Ice Cream.

But if you want unique, hand-crafted, premium ice creams made for grown ups who want to suck the marrow out of life then shop Cold Case Ice Cream by clicking on the "Shop" buttons below.

Nominate the most tasteless person you know in 3 simple steps

1.) Enter your email in the form below.

2.) Click "Next" and nominate a friend by entering their email.

3.) Check your inbox for your 10% off coupon.

If your nominee is chosen, we'll send them a tub of Flavorless Ice Cream and you'll receive 6 pints of premium Cold Case Ice Cream for FREE.

Shipping Popup

Flavors in this case:

  • White Christmas Crack

    White Christmas Crack

    Decadent white chocolate ice cream complemented by caramelized saltine cracker bits, dusted with candy cane and swirled with rich white chocolate hot fudge sauce.
  • Smashing Pumpkins

    Smashing Pumpkins

    Creamy vanilla ice cream interspersed with delectable homemade pumpkin bread pieces and dark chocolate fudge whirls.
  • Sticky Bandits

    Sticky Bandits

    Luscious vanilla ice cream ribboned with rich butterscotch swirls and generous chunks of green apple sticky toffee pudding cake.
  • Crime & Peppermint

    Crime & Peppermint

    A refreshing blend of finely ground candy cane ice cream, overflowing with scrumptious Oreo cookie bits.
  • Eggnog Espionage

    Eggnog Espionage

    Smooth spiced eggnog ice cream packed with delicious chunks of Biscoff cookies.
  • Chocolate Orange Jumpsuit

    Chocolate Orange Jumpsuit

    Luxurious dark chocolate orange ice cream accentuated with zesty orange peel and tangy orange curd swirls.
Shop Now

Shipping Popup

Filter By:

Assaulted Caramel
+

Assaulted Caramel

Rich salted caramel ice cream melded with Madagascar vanilla and fresh cream.
Cereal Killer
+

Cereal Killer

Milk chocolate base with homemade muddy buddy cereal mix with swirls of peanut butter.
Cookies & Scream
+

Cookies & Scream

Sweet cream ice cream covered in a gratuitous amount of Oreo cookie chunks.
Creamy Contraband
+

Creamy Contraband

Fresh sweet cream ice cream base mingled with pure Madagascar vanilla.
Embezzle-mint
+

Embezzle-mint

Madagascar vanilla ice cream mixed with fresh mint leaf and semi sweet chocolate stracciatella.
Flight Risk
+

Flight Risk

Vanilla ice cream layered with cookie butter chunks and cookie butter swirls covered in golden cinnamon cream.
Jane Dough
+

Jane Dough

Sweet cream base with golden syrup and Belgian chocolate chip cookie dough & cookie chunks.
Killer Bees
+

Killer Bees

Sweet cream base infused with drizzles of fresh honey and chunks of honeycomb candy.
Rocky Railroad Robbery
+

Rocky Railroad Robbery

Dark chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, homemade almond brittle and vanilla marshmallow fluff swirls.
Smashing Pumpkins
+

Smashing Pumpkins

Creamy vanilla ice cream interspersed with delectable homemade pumpkin bread pieces and dark chocolate fudge whirls.
Strawburied Alive
+

Strawburied Alive

Sweet cream base blended with fresh strawberries.
Trial By Chocolate
+

Trial By Chocolate

Sweet and creamy Cocoa ice cream infused with pure Madagascar vanilla.

INVESTIGATE OUR

Eye Witness Testimonials

“This ice cream is insane! I loved EVERY. SINGLE. BITE. Where did they get these ingredients? They were fancy AF. Honestly, the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted in my life. Case closed!”
Joseph R. [REDACTED]

“In a word, epic. The flavors were so wild and different. I’ve never had ice cream that was so different and yet so familiar. Like pineapple & cornbread?! Who knew. It was like all my favorite flavors on steroids.”
Renny G. [REDACTED]

“I had really high expectations because of the price. KEEP your expectations high. This isn’t just the best ice cream I’ve ever had it was the best dessert I’ve ever had, period. “
Eden M. [REDACTED]