Clearance Levels

Insider Tiers

The deeper you go, the better the perks. Advance through our ranks with every purchase.

Perks & Benefits Henchman Henchman 1000 pts Most Popular Hitman Hitman 2000 pts Mob Boss Mob Boss 5000 pts
Earning
Points per $1 spent10 pts11 pts12 pts
Welcome bonus100 pts200 pts300 pts
Birthday rewardFree Birthday Pint*Free Birthday Pint*Free Birthday 3-Pack
Shipping & Discounts
Free shipping on all orders✓✓✓
Merch discounts - 20% Off—✓✓
Access & Exclusives
Shop with points✓✓✓
Early access to new flavors—✓✓
Vote on upcoming flavors—✓✓
Annual mystery gift——✓
Access to exclusive merch——✓
Join Free Start Earning Learn More
Henchman
Henchman
1000 pts
Earning
Points per $1 spent 10 pts
Welcome bonus 100 pts
Birthday reward Free Birthday Pint*
Shipping & Discounts
Free shipping on all orders ✓
Merch discounts - 20% Off —
Access & Exclusives
Shop with points ✓
Early access to new flavors —
Vote on upcoming flavors —
Annual mystery gift —
Access to exclusive merch —
Join Free
Most Popular
Hitman
Hitman
2000 pts
Earning
Points per $1 spent 11 pts
Welcome bonus 200 pts
Birthday reward Free Birthday Pint*
Shipping & Discounts
Free shipping on all orders ✓
Merch discounts - 20% Off ✓
Access & Exclusives
Shop with points ✓
Early access to new flavors ✓
Vote on upcoming flavors ✓
Annual mystery gift —
Access to exclusive merch —
Start Earning
Mob Boss
Mob Boss
5000 pts
Earning
Points per $1 spent 12 pts
Welcome bonus 300 pts
Birthday reward Free Birthday 3-Pack
Shipping & Discounts
Free shipping on all orders ✓
Merch discounts - 20% Off ✓
Access & Exclusives
Shop with points ✓
Early access to new flavors ✓
Vote on upcoming flavors ✓
Annual mystery gift ✓
Access to exclusive merch ✓
Learn More

Ways To Earn

  • Purchase Cold Case Products

    Purchase Cold Case products and you will earn points for every dollar spent.

  • Creating Rewards Account

    Earn 100 points for creating a Cold Case Ice Cream rewards account.

  • Birthday Bonus

    Enter your birthday in Cold Case Ice Cream rewards and you'll receive 100 points.

  • Follow us on Social Media

    Earn points when you follow us on social media - Facebook, Instagram, X, TikTok.

  • Submit a Review

    Get points when you submit a review
Sign Up/Login

Redeem Points

  • 1,000 Points = $10 Off

    Redeem 1000 points for $10 off your next purchase.

  • Free Build Your Own Case

    Redeem 10,000 points for a Free Build Your Own Case
Redeem Points
Redeem Points