NOMINATE SOMEONE AND

Win Flavorless Ice Cream!

Here at Cold Case Ice Cream, we're all about the bold and the beautiful in ice cream flavors. But guess what?

We've heard that some folks think our creations are too much of a good thing.

For those with... let's say 'numb tongues', we've introduced Flavorless Ice Cream.

It's as unadventurous as it gets, perfect for those who prefer their world a little less flavorful.

But, for the rest of you flavor daredevils who want unique, hand-crafted, premium ice creams made for grown ups who want to suck the marrow out of life, shop Cold Case Ice Cream by clicking on the "Shop" buttons below.
  • 24 Karat Cake

    Nutmeg cinnamon brown sugar ice cream with carrot cake crumbles and cream cheese frosting bites sprinkled with edible gold flakes.

  • Honey Arson

    Fresh key-lime ice cream with caramelized amber honey flakes.

  • Black Market Raspberry

    Fresh black raspberry ice cream loaded with Oreo cookie chunks.

  • Banana Split & Run

    Banana ice cream with fresh banana and crispy butterfinger candy bits swirled with hazelnut spread.

     

     

  • Mango Triad

    Coconut ice cream with cooked sweet rice and fresh mango puree.

     

  • Malted Milk Brawl

    Dark chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and crispy malted milk balls. 

Filter By:

America's Most Wanted
+

America's Most Wanted

Better Than Sex Cake
+

Better Than Sex Cake

Blackmail
+

Blackmail

Campfire Carnage
+

Campfire Carnage

Cereal Killer
+

Cereal Killer

Convict Crunch
+

Convict Crunch

Cookie Mobster
+

Cookie Mobster

Crime Brûlée
+

Crime Brûlée

Flight Risk
+

Flight Risk

Huckleberry Pie Witness
+

Huckleberry Pie Witness

Illegal Fireworks
+

Illegal Fireworks

Killer Bees
+

Killer Bees

Miami Ice
+

Miami Ice

Stone Cold Killer
+

Stone Cold Killer

INVESTIGATE OUR

Eye Witness Testimonials

“This ice cream is insane! I loved EVERY. SINGLE. BITE. Where did they get these ingredients? They were fancy AF. Honestly, the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted in my life. Case closed!”

Joseph R. [REDACTED]

“In a word, epic. The flavors were so wild and different. I’ve never had ice cream that was so different and yet so familiar. Like pineapple & cornbread?! Who knew. It was like all my favorite flavors on steroids.”

Renny G. [REDACTED]

“I had really high expectations because of the price. KEEP your expectations high. This isn’t just the best ice cream I’ve ever had it was the best dessert I’ve ever had, period. “

Eden M. [REDACTED]