Skip to product information
1 of 8

Holiday Heist: 3-Month Subscription

Holiday Heist: 3-Month Subscription

Regular price $419.97 USD
Regular price Sale price $419.97 USD
Sale Sold out

6 Luxury Pints

Our High-End Party Box is filled with: 

    • 6 Handcrafted Specialty Pints of Ice Cream

    • Sticky Bandits: Luscious vanilla ice cream ribboned with rich butterscotch swirls and generous chunks of green apple sticky toffee pudding cake.

    • Smashing Pumpkins: Creamy vanilla ice cream interspersed with delectable homemade pumpkin bread pieces and dark chocolate fudge whirls.

    • Crime & Peppermint: A refreshing blend of finely ground candy cane ice cream, overflowing with scrumptious Oreo cookie bits.

    • Chocolate Orange Jumpsuit: Luxurious dark chocolate orange ice cream accentuated with zesty orange peel and tangy orange curd swirls. 

    • White Christmas Crack: Decadent white chocolate ice cream complemented by caramelized saltine cracker bits, dusted with candy cane and swirled with rich white chocolate hot fudge sauce.

    • Eggnog Espionage: Smooth spiced eggnog ice cream packed with delicious chunks of Biscoff cookies.Exclusive Cold Case Mystery Game

  • Golden File with Flavor Profiles
  • 1 Gold Shovel Spoon in Evidence Bag

Whether you're hosting a party, sending a luxury gift, or just indulging yourself, the evidence always leads to Cold Case Ice Cream. Get it now. The clock is ticking...

Regular price $419.97 USD
Regular price Sale price $419.97 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping $25.00 FREE SHIPPING


  • Arrives In High-End Black & Gold Cold Cooler Evidence Box
  • 1 Golden Shovel Spoon
  • 6 Pints of Award-Winning LIMITED EDITION Luxury Ice Cream (Featured Below)
  • Exclusive Cold Case Mystery Game
  • Incident Reports Detailing Mysterious Flavor Profiles
View full details
  • Caught Red Handed

    Caught Red Handed

    Chocolate hazelnut ice cream with red velvet cake chunks and cream cheese frosting swirl.
  • Better Than Sex Cake

    Better Than Sex Cake

    Milk chocolate ice cream with soaked chocolate cake, caramel, toffee bits, and marshmallow swirl.
  • Raspberry Ransom

    Raspberry Ransom

    Raspberry ice cream with a white chocolate ganache swirl and cinnamon brownie chunks.
  • Miami Ice

    Miami Ice

    Pina colada dairy-free ice cream with coconut cream, pineapple, and a strawberry balsamic swirl.
  • Jail Break Birthday Cake

    Jail Break Birthday Cake

    Birthday cake ice cream with white cake pieces, buttercream swirls, and sprinkles.
  • Cherry Bomb Threat

    Cherry Bomb Threat

    Dark cherry ice cream with milk chocolate bits, a dangerously delightful mix.

Looking for Something a Little More Custom?

Build Your Case

The evidence looks delicious. It's time for you to build a case against your hunger by selecting exactly which flavors you want.

Shop Now


Eye Witness Testimonials

“This ice cream is insane! I loved EVERY. SINGLE. BITE. Where did they get these ingredients? They were fancy AF. Honestly, the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted in my life. Case closed!”

Joseph R. [REDACTED]

“In a word, epic. The flavors were so wild and different. I’ve never had ice cream that was so different and yet so familiar. Like pineapple & cornbread?! Who knew. It was like all my favorite flavors on steroids.”


“I had really high expectations because of the price. KEEP your expectations high. This isn’t just the best ice cream I’ve ever had it was the best dessert I’ve ever had, period. “



When Will There Be New Flavors?

Curious about what we've got planned? Sign up for our email list to find out, but keep in mind - snitches get stitches. Hint: it's coming sooner than you think.

How Do You Ship Ice Cream?

We don't mess around with our frozen goods - we give them the VIP treatment, packing them in an insulated shipping box with enough dry ice to keep them colder than the hearts of the most devious of criminals. At a frigid -109.3°F, these frozen culprits are ready to be delivered in perfect condition.

Can I Purchase Multiple Boxes for Corporate Gifting?

Yes! It’s possibly the easiest yet most thoughtful gift you could give vendors, contractors, clients, or a whole customer service team. (Let’s face it, they are the backbone of this economy) If you’re looking to place an order of 5 or more, head here, fill out the form, and our team will get back to you!.